Wireless--------AP----------Router---------Internet STAs 1-2 | | Wireless----------------------+ STAs 3-4All four stations should be assigned IP addresses in the same subnet. The router serves as the default gateway for all four stations, and must relay all intra-WLAN traffic out the right switch port to reach each station's MAC address. Based on your description, I think your router may not be relaying traffic for Wireless STAs #1 and #2 out the switch port that's connected to your AP.
If you are not using the DHCP server on your Router to assign dynamic IP addresses to all four stations, try that first. If that doesn't help, or you need to use static IP addresses, see if your router has a configuration option for static ARP entries. Configuring static ARP table entries on the router so that traffic for Wireless Stations #1 and #2 are mapped to the AP's router-facing MAC address might help. You can also try configuring static ARP entries on your Wireless STAs #3 and #4 -- your router or AP may not be responding to ARP requests on behalf of Wireless STAs #1 and #2, so #3 and #4 can't "find" them on the LAN. To debug this, try using the Windows 2000 arp and tracert commands to see where intra-WLAN packets are being sent and how far they get.
Dig Deeper on Mobile networking
Related Q&A from Lisa Phifer
Is there a difference between a wireless access point vs. a router? Yes -- while the two wireless devices are related, they meet different needs in a... Continue Reading
Learn the differences between site-to-site VPNs vs. remote-access VPNs and find out about the protocols, benefits and the data security methods used ... Continue Reading
Need to send an email, check your flight's status or get ready for a presentation? You can do it all on your smartwatch, thanks to a slew of Apple ... Continue Reading