In one installation, I need to put four access points in four corners of a building (yes there are better ways); the key question is how do I connect those APs to the main switch/router without running CAT 5 cables, as that might not be possible. In other words, I'd like to know of other products that allow me to reuse the phone wiring already installed.
I want to know my options and then a recommended solution based on quality product, capacity then price.
Long Range Ethernet (LRE) is a Cisco solution that uses VDSL modulation to support symmetric Ethernet over unshielded twisted-pair inside wiring -- aka Plain Old Telephone Service (POTS) lines already installed inside your walls. LRE supports full-duplex Ethernet up to 15 Mbps and 5000 feet, and can coexist with analog or digital voice services, including ISDN and ADSL. You'd need an LRE-capable switch (e.g., the Cisco Catalyst 2924...
LRE XL) and a termination device for each Ethernet drop (e.g., the Cisco 575 LRE CPE). You'd connect each AP to a 575 LRE CPE, plug that CPE device into the nearest RJ-11 telephone jack, and haul traffic back to one centrally-located Catalyst switch. A new LRE-capable switch will set you back at least $2500, plus perhaps $120 per CPE device.
Another option is HomePNA, defined by the Home Phoneline Networking Alliance. As the name suggests, this technology is largely designed for use inside the home, allowing broadband Internet traffic, video traffic, and voice all share the same POTS lines. HomePNA 3.0, an extension of version 2.0 (now an ITU standard) can support up to 128 Mbps of traffic. Depending upon your environment, you might be able to use HomePNA in your office -- but HomePNA can't share POTS lines with a PBX system. You'd interconnect your APs using HomePNA bridges. With only four APs, this would cost you less than LRE; for example, the Linksys HPB200 HomePNA-to-10 Mbps Ethernet bridge retails for about $170.
Finally, there's HomePlug, defined by the HomePlug Powerline Alliance. HomePlug competes directly with HomePNA for interconnecting devices within the home, but rides over existing electrical cables instead of twisted-pair telephone lines, reaching speeds up to 14 Mbps. One drawback of HomePlug is the variable interference caused by noisy devices sharing the same powerline -- for example, have you ever seen your household lights dim when using your printer, fax machine, or microwave oven? HomePlug devices are built to detect and adapt to this interference, but noise sources may be greater in an office environment. HomePlug products are even cheaper than HomePNA -- for example, the Linksys PLEBR10 Instant PowerLine Etherfast 10/100 Bridge now retails for around $80.
Dig Deeper on Wireless LANs
Related Q&A from Lisa Phifer, Wireless Expert
Are Cisco 1200 access points operated in “thick” or autonomous mode or as a thin AP, a lightweight access point that is controlled by a central ...continue reading
Wireless expert, Lisa Phifer addresses a query regarding Wi-Fi replacing Ethernet. Lisa provides analysis, advantages and disadvantages, and future ...continue reading
Lisa Phifer explains multiple access point configuration when a device tries to differentiate transmitted signals from each point and explains ...continue reading
Have a question for an expert?
Please add a title for your question
Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.